India’s EV market welcomed two strong contenders in the mid-SUV and compact crossover segments: the Tata Curvv EV and the MG Windsor EV. Here's a side-by-side comparison to help you choose.
Design and Styling
Tata Curvv EV:
- Bold coupe-SUV design with sloping rooflines and sporty LED lighting.
- Five monotone color options like Virtual Sunrise and Flame Red.
- Gesture-controlled motorized tailgate for added sophistication.
MG Windsor EV:
- Minimalist, aerodynamically sleek crossover with large 18-inch alloy wheels.
- Four vibrant colors including Turquoise Green and Clay Beige.
- Sleek, flush-type door handles and a charging flap at the front.
Verdict: The Curvv EV boasts a sporty edge, while the Windsor EV emphasizes minimalist elegance.
Interior Features and Comfort
Tata Curvv EV:
- Panoramic sunroof, 12.3-inch touchscreen, and digital driver display.
- Wireless charging, ventilated front seats, and customizable mood lighting.
- 500-liter boot capacity for ample storage.
MG Windsor EV:
- Luxurious cabin with leatherette upholstery and wooden accents.
- Massive 15.6-inch infotainment screen and reclining rear seats.
- 604-liter boot capacity, ideal for larger luggage.
Verdict: The Windsor EV excels in luxury and space, but the Curvv EV offers impressive tech and practicality.
Performance and Range
Tata Curvv EV:
- Two battery options: 55 kWh (585 km ARAI range) and 45 kWh (502 km ARAI range).
- Accelerates from 0-100 km/h in 8.6 seconds with a top speed of 160 km/h.
- Features Vehicle-to-Load (V2L) and Vehicle-to-Vehicle (V2V) charging for added utility.
MG Windsor EV:
- Equipped with a 38 kWh LFP battery offering an ARAI range of 331 km.
- Delivers 134 bhp power and 200 Nm torque.
- Accelerates from 0-100 km/h in 11 seconds with a top speed of 140 km/h.
- Comes with four driving modes: Eco, Eco+, Normal, and Sport, for tailored performance.
Verdict: The Curvv EV leads in range, acceleration, and top speed, making it better suited for long-distance and high-performance driving. The Windsor EV, while slower, offers a balanced urban-friendly package.
Charging Capabilities
Tata Curvv EV:
- DC fast charging adds 150 km of range in just 15 minutes.
- 10-80% charge completed in 40 minutes with a fast charger.
MG Windsor EV:
- DC fast charging from 0-80% in 55 minutes.
Verdict: The Curvv EV leads with faster charging times.
Safety and Technology
Tata Curvv EV:
- Level 2 ADAS with features like adaptive cruise control and emergency braking.
- Reinforced body and BNCAP 5-star readiness.
- Acoustic Vehicle Alert System (AVAS) for pedestrian safety.
MG Windsor EV:
- Level 2 ADAS with 360-degree camera and six airbags.
- Lifetime battery warranty for first owners, unlimited kilometers.
Verdict: Both excel in safety, but the Windsor EV’s battery warranty is a standout.
Pricing and Ownership Options
Tata Curvv EV:
- Priced between Rs. 17.49 lakh and Rs. 21.99 lakh (introductory, ex-showroom).
- Bookings have been open since August 2024.
MG Windsor EV:
- Offers two pricing models:
- Standard Ownership: Rs. 13.49 lakh to Rs. 15.49 lakh (introductory, ex-showroom).
- Battery-as-a-Service (BaaS): Rs. 9.99 lakh to Rs. 11.99 lakh (introductory, ex-showroom), with an additional monthly subscription cost for battery usage.
- BaaS reduces the upfront purchase price and allows buyers to pay for battery usage on a per-kilometer basis.
- Bookings have been open since October 2024.
Verdict: The Windsor EV's dual pricing model, especially the BaaS program, provides flexibility and makes it more accessible to budget-conscious buyers.
Final Thoughts
The Tata Curvv EV offers superior range, performance, and a bold design for those seeking a premium EV. Meanwhile, the MG Windsor EV impresses with its affordability, luxury features, and innovative ownership options.
For long-distance travel and performance, go for the Curvv EV. If affordability and a luxurious touch are key, the Windsor EV is your best bet.
